PROFESSOR PRICE
  • Blog
  • Megaregions
  • Courses
  • Trip Info
  • C.V. & Research
  • Transformational Ministry
  • Contact
    • About
  • French
  • Missional Church
  • Gospel & Culture
  • Global Diversity
  • History | Church of the Nazarene

Warning Signs Everywhere--Review "Pilot S1.E1" Fear the Walking Dead (AMC)

8/29/2015

0 Comments

 
Fear the Walking Dead is part-spinoff and part-origin-story for the popular AMC series The Walking Dead based on the graphic novel of the same title by Robert Kirkman. A brief internet search will turn up plenty of content about the cable series and the graphic novels. Basically, it tells the story of an unknown disease that turns the recently dead into wandering cannibals seeking flesh to eat.
Picture
Cast photo from season four of AMC's The Walking Dead. Image taken from Walking Dead Obsessed, a Wordpress site created by a 50-year grandmother and fan of the show.
Picture
The first family of Fear the Walking Dead, premieres August 24, 2015. (l to r) Kim Dickens as Maddie Clark, Cliff Curtis as Travis Manawa, Alycia Debnam-Carey as Alicia Clark, Frank Dillane as Nick Clark
Waking Up to a World Gone Mad
I am predisposed toward wanting to love the next iteration of the world created by The Walking Dead. The stories are compelling and the questions stark: What would I do if I woke up to a world gone mad? Would I have what it takes to survive? Each character provides insights into how to respond to these questions.

Both the original series and the spinoff borrow a lede from the zombie flick 28 Days Later (2002) by having a main character wake up into this world. The viewer follows the slowly unfolding realization that the definition of yesterday's reality no longer holds true. I like this way of entering the story, although it is not geared to a fast-paced action thriller. The "explosions" and "chases" are inward as the mind races to figure out what is going on, and the heart palpitates with what is waiting around the next corner.
Notice in the first scene of the premiere of Fear the Walking Dead (FTWD) how this theme of light emanating naturally from the outside plays continually against artificial light of the interiors. A later scene in the abandoned church uses a hanging light bulb to great effect. What is real and what is not? What is living and what is not?
Picture
Think of the artificial lights of the hospital room and equipment and the helicopter searchlights at night. This dawning realization is lived out by Nick, the main character/drugged out prodigal. Nick in a conversation with Travis in the hospital room furthers the metaphor: "Either it was in the powder [the drug he took] or it came out of me." What is the origin myth that we're talking about? If this show lives up to its predecessors, the story being told is probably not the one we're thinking of.
Religious Cries in the Night
The first words spoken in the FTWD premiere take place in a church, as Nick shouts for "Gloria." We find out he is searching for his companion, a fellow junkie. But, it's obvious, as it goes with this universe and its story, there is more to it. A sickened, lonely human  wandering through a dilapidated sanctuary seeking someone else. The character moves toward the safety of being close to someone else. The religious themes are reinforced by outer ilght piercing the darkened hallways as Nick moves through the church.

The next scene after the opening credits is a house--a lived in, cared for building--that is truly a home. A woman moves through the house, starting in the bedroom, picking up laundry, while a man works on a kitchen sink. The first conversation between the Maddie and Travis has them bantering about the broken pipe. Travis is under the sink.
Maddie: "How's that working out, babe?"
Travis: "Ye of little faith."
Maddie: "Ye of no faith. The plumber's number is on the fridge."
 
It's a small bit of dialogue but important in that it shows the posture of the two characters: unwillingness to believe any sort of fixing actually works, and a willingness to try fixing it, regardless. 

In the hospital later, Nick spoke to his mom for the first time after an accident.
Maddie: "What happened?"
Nick: "L. A. is not a pedestrian-safe city."
Maddie. "Nick."
NIck: "Just trying to be the light."

Not only does this echo the continuing religious themes, but it might be a clue to Nick's role in this series. He seems to see things before others do.

Nick told Travis about the procedures of the "junkie communion" with a story that ends with a perverse reversal in the "eating of flesh." A religious theme, just not conventional.

On the return trip to the abandoned church, the lopsided cross moves across the screen followed by "Why?" spray painted on a column in the sanctuary. 

The religious themes are not so subtle in this first episode. As with the original series, this world turns churches into places where, as Maddie put it, "bad things happened."
No Place Is Safe
The first fifteen minutes are set the following locations: an abandoned church, a domesticated yet distressed home (mostly the kitchen, the place of most familiarity), a busy hospital, a car on commute to work, and a packed high school.

These scenes represent fundamental institutions in American society. All of these institutions are bound to be infected and disintegrate like a corpse. What will be lost? Orange juice for breakfast, hot showers every morning, running water, leisure for creative arts, mobile phones, reading novels, following conspiracies on the internet. If all of this withers away and disappears, will there still be a human will to survive? Will there be a reason to survive?

I use the language of survival because it is so critical to the story line of the original series. There are survivors and those that cannot survive. Remember the dialogue between Abraham and Glen in the library? Remember the scene between Calvin and Nick in the drainage basin with skeleton figures tagged on the concrete wall? Some live, and some die. As Jack London reminded high schoolers, we have to learn the desire to be the ones to not die.

Think of the code Rick and his group live by in the original series. Consider how often rules and bending rules are brought up in these scenes from FTWD: 
  • in the home, everyone is running late, trying to start the day on time determined by the society around them 
  • in the hospital, Maddie walks past nurses, doctors, and police officers to see her son
  • in the school, Tobias tries to bring a weapon into school, while Maddie tries to enforce these rules
  • in the hospital, Nick describes the process of "junkie communion" and how his experience with Gloria went counter to "normal"
  • in the school, Russell fell asleep in class because he isn't interested in how to start a fire because he has a stove at home
  • in the hospital when the nurse made an exception for Nick
  • in the media, the viral video is proclaimed as "fake" by Alicia
  • in watching the video, a teenage girl acknowledges one of the first rules learned by survivors facing walkers when it is shot in the head by the police.
The code eventually breaks down. The institutions crumble, become warped, and then must be patched back together. Warning signs for what is coming appear in a few short minutes. 
  • Travis told his students, "It's about Man vs. Nature. Nature always wins."
  • The gurgling patient beside Nick goes into arrest. 
  • Travis and Maddie pass a "no walkers" I mean, "no walking" sign
  • A series of lost children posters.  
Picture
Picture
And, then, the walker-like homeless guy in the park. All of these scenes depict the sheltered, ordered life in contemporary America, and the fleeting and sometimes dangerous struggle of this existence.
Picture
Picture
Picture
A Study in Belonging
The hapless father figure in Travis Manawa, played by Cliff Curtis, calls the ex-SO/mother of his only son about an upcoming custody weekend. Travis tells his son that "we're just trying to build a family here." He moves from this failed conversation to one with his new signficant other, Madison, the mother of the drug addict, played by a favorite actor of mine Kim Dickens, with much more success in finding resolution.
Picture
Travis continually tries to fix these family situations in the face of doubt. In the truck on the highway, Maddie is not sure she wants her son to come home. The impetus of the show so far is that the character conflicts are so plausible. The decomposition of the family is a key plot point as well as how well people can keep it together; as much as The Walking Dead is about the composition of fictive kin while trying to keep it together. Watching the viral video in the teacher's lounge, Artie, the school principal, said, "This is why we need to stay at home." Contrast this talk of "home" with Cal and Nick meeting in the diner. Cal said to Nick, "I got you" and called him "brother" even though it's not certain how true it is.
The interactions between Travis and Maddie are the core to the show--a study of contrasts: certain doubt and dubious belief. Notice the small moments between these two. The image above just before answering the phone, and again in the hospital before Maddie leaves for school. Master actors creating the ideal image for the kind of people that could survive anything.
Alicia the daughter has a side plot with a boyfriend showing the fragility of family relationships and continual search for belonging somewhere to someone. The connection between her and her brother Nick seems like something I'd like them to explore in future episodes. Tobias, a geeky conspiracy freak, always in danger of being bullied, becomes another challenge to the notion of belonging. Who belongs to whom, who can be trusted, and does it matter in long run?

The answer is yes--all of this belonging matters in terms of survival, in developing the desire to not die. The episode demonstrates the versatility of working through domestic strife in a rapid exchange of words in the hospital room between Travis, Maddie, Nick and Alicia at 8:10-9:10. It is a great piece of work between these actors. This is followed by the phone call between Travis and his ex  and his son, which Travis called "something resembling love."

Later, Nick's story told to Travis about what happened the morning of the first scene, being together with Gloria and then waking up to the horror of being left but not alone. Put this up against the mother and son embrace in the drainage basin, when there was no dialogue, just powerful imagery. Good stuff if you think about it a little bit. It's a better show than most "first to post" reviewers thought.
Portals and Fences
Notice the image of portals and fences throughout the first episode. Nick moving from room to room in the church, Maddie making her way to Nick's hospital room through a series of doors, the scanner at the school entrance, the fence surrounding the church, the wall by the park with the lost-child posters, the wall alongside the street in front of the homeless guy in the park, the school bus entry door, the exit ramp where the viral video is taken, the car doors on at least three vehicles. and the portal for the Los Angeles River drainage basin. 

There seemed to be a major revelation to the characters every time they passed through a portal.
Blue-eyed Walkers
A thought crossed my mind. Long-time fans know about Breaking Bad's blue meth Easter egg showing up in The Walking Dead in Merle and Daryle's contraband. 
Picture
Picture
Source: Imgur.com, user: Dr Ron Swanson (click image for page)
The first walker revealed in The Walking Dead universe has crystal (meth) blue eyes. Is there something to it? Not to mention the pervasive drug use that is tied to the main character Nick, and the possibility that he had been given tainted goods by his dealer. Could bad drugs be a cause of the diseased walkers?
Picture
It's important to remember to look for throwaway lines. It's in these morsels that much can be heard. Travis, Nick, and Maddie are in the truck driving through the drainage basin portal. They are talking about Nick's drug dealer. 

Travis: "We don't know what we're dealing with here, Maddie." 
Maddie: "I do." 

So, is there drug abuse in Maddie's past? Is it the motivation for her to go into high school counseling? The reason her kids have an unmentioned father? Is there a connection between a Los Angeles high school counselor and a high school chemistry teacher in Albuquerque?

The first episode poses a few interesting questions, and makes for a fun few weeks while the rest of the story rolls out.
0 Comments

Tripping into Grace--Review of Theology of Luck: Fate, Chaos, and Faith by Rob Fringer and Jeff Lane (Beacon Hill Press, 2015)

8/26/2015

0 Comments

 
TL;dr Lots of the book seemed like a extended version of  a term paper written for a seminary class, but there were redemptive bits providing more than food for thought but also maybe a better way to think of what it means to be in relationship with the Divine.
I wanted to like this book out of the sheer pleasure of the title: how can someone not smirk ironically at a title like a “theology of luck.” The first few chapters veered toward the idea of “luck” in religious experience and then swerved back into territory mostly familiar to the seminarian.
The first chapter, for instance, cites the first century heretic Marcion, 17th century philosopher Leibnitz, 18th century intellectuals both secular--Voltaire--and clergy--John Wesley, 20th century resident atheist Richard Dawkins, seminary professors Frank Tupper and Michael Gorman, throws in a random Latin phrase about the Trinity, and on the same page includes a string of unquoted biblical verses stretching from Genesis to Revelation. 
Even with the lofty beginning that made this professor want to set it down, I felt like I needed to mark it for a grade but for summer break, until there appeared this gem of a morsel of a great idea on page 31: “So, then, the God of the universe is the God who has demonstrated a willingness to initiate but a hesitance to dominate.” New paragraph for the next line: “This is a difficult concept for many.” Okay, let’s go there, the coffee's hot and there's a week left before classes start, but alas the authors did not or at least they skated around this concept for the rest of the book but did not jump completely into the fray. Instead, they enjoy the plausible deniability of holding a paradox (see page 33) and willowy notions of relationship with the Divine. I'm a recovering educational psychologist, and I believe the human psyche is important but there's so much more to religious faith than personal perceptions.
I almost backed out completely by page 41 in the middle of the chapter entitled "Lucky?" Here there was an expectation of jumping in the deep end, but it is written, “Why does it matter to us what the world thinks of our God? Because it matters to God.” Huh? As I read the words of God’s interactions with Abraham and Issac and Jacob and the prophets, filtered through Jewish rabbinical tradition with a low threshold for drek, and then Jesus' dialogue with the first disciples and religious leaders, filtered through intellectually honest gospel writers, I do not think this notion of divine like-ability ever entered God’s self-revelation. I cannot even think of a single place in Scripture where this is the case. I could be wrong. Let me know if you find a moment in Scripture where this happens.
The absence of engaging folk traditions in popular religiosity and similar beliefs among adherents of Islam, Hinduism, and its cousin Buddhism was, in a word, disappointing. Even my neighbors in the American Appalachian region have all kinds of practices that entertain the avoidance of bad luck and the search for certainty. Hex signs on the side of Amish barns come to mind as well as planting by the phases of the moon might just help a crop produce bountifully or wither on the vine. The summer of 2015 brought about a rare instance of a blue moon, when a full moon happens twice in an astrological sign—as one blogger put it “a lunar bonus round” for the Wiccan community, also very much a part of my neck of the woods. Fun fact--The term “blue moon” was first recorded in a 16th century letter by Cardinal Wolsey in defense of Henry VIII of England against the “wily foxes” of the clergy who “say the moon is blue, we must believe that it is true.” 
All this to say, a cursory search, not even a scholarly one, turned up many examples of luck and fate; none of these beliefs and practices are seriously engaged in the early chapters. The authors do engage books resting on seminary shelves, such as those written by Greg Boyd and John Sanders. Luck is defined away as "irrational," and natural disasters are blamed on the “brokenness of this world.” (page 42) Um, okay. At the same time, the proposed solution is found in the inter-relatedness of all things under God’s purview, which seems like a momentary lapse in logic: Move long, God can still do what he wants, so whatever. Maybe I read through this section too fast.
The jargon continues with a parachute drop of a phrase like “compatibilist view” into the middle of a paragraph without any context (page 48_. The argument against deterministic views then glides over biblical examples of Pharaoh’s heart-hardening in Exodus and the selection by lots of Matthias as one of the Twelve in the Book of Acts. These are fascinating cases and could have been examined more thoroughly. It is my personal view that the apostles leapt in front of the Holy Spirit’s moving and selected a new apostle that is never mentioned again in Scripture, yet another young, though very unsavory, man named Saul is introduced in Acts 7:58, and will go on to pen 60% of the New Testament as Paul the apostle. First year university students in Bible are always curious about Pharaoh and his hardened heart. Does God create the context for disobedience as well as obedience? Does the Divine stack the deck against his creatures? Am I just a pawn on a giant chessboard? These biblical cases were a mother lode of insight (it's why they are biblical) but not to be fully excavated.
As harsh the review might seem so far, the book takes a welcome turn with a reflection upon the story of Joseph. I kept wondering if Joseph's tale, though was about luck or just existing within God’s sphere of awareness. The authors return to this idea of divine awareness in the final chapters. Their treatment of Joseph showed promise, and it very well could have anchored the entire book. There’s a lot to work with there. 
Speaking of divine awareness, living under the sun, so to speak, I like the powerful Hebrew word “shamar” at work throughout the Hebrew Scriptures, and into the Gospels and Pauline letters. It is one of the single most powerful metaphors in all of Scripture. Shamar appears first in Genesis: “The Lord God took the man and put him in the Garden of Eden to work it and take care of it” (Genesis 2:15) – to work it and shamar it. It appears again in Genesis 4, the fratricidal Cain asks of God, "Am I my brother’s keeper”—brother’s shamar-er. Psalm 121 has eight occurrences related to God’s deep and abiding care for His people. 

The concept of "watching over" continues with the search for a king found finally in the shepherd boy David, sought for by the prophets, especially Ezekiel (chapter 34), and revealed to shepherds as the Good Shepherd in Jesus. Paul talks about church leaders as an "episkopos" or overseer, like a shepherd. I thought the authors were going to go this way at the bottom of page 146. Whew. They did not, although they write of stewardship in the broad sense. I think I need to write a book on “shamar” before someone beats me to it.
The book then turns to chaos and fate. There is sense that chaos is simply brought about by disobedience, even though it is there in Genesis 1:1 in the “formless void.” I think I need to ask Eric Vail about this, I mean, he wrote a whole dissertation on the subject of chaos and creation. 

Engaging the Muslim belief of kismet and the Judeo-Christian response via Michael Lodahl’s Claiming Abraham (2010) would have been an interesting conversation. I wonder if "pockets of chaos" can be avoided, such is the promise of the talisman, or simply endured like Job. 

And, I wonder if Job would have viewed God’s grace as a “gentle and gracious correction” (page 71)? Just wondering.

Now for the Good Parts, IMO
As much as I have conveyed some criticism so far, the book is worth a read just for what it says about manipulation, obedience, and vocation. The counterpoint of obedience to manipulation in chapter 4 is probably the single most important idea in the book. Obedience is equated with hearing. This is a point I make in freshman Bible class, in preaching, and in casual conversation. It makes the Shema (Deuteronomy 6:4: “Hear, O Israel . . . “) all the more poignant. People love the Lord only through obedience which only happens when one hears. The one who hears cannot easily manipulate the Other with sugary words and stylized ritual so common in consumeristic religious practices. 

The manic arts are prevalent in the Church, and the authors call out bibliomancy (page 84): Opening the Bible, reading a verse and taking action because it was meant to be. Nope. It was just a lazy reading of the Bible. Good for the authors. A needed correction here for the tendency to be satisfied with making consumers instead of disciples, more willing to “get something out of it” than “follow the Rabbi no matter how long it takes.” The argument continues in a later section on authority, in which true disciples are said to share a “conferred authority” with God and return it in true worship “not through acquiescence or manipulation but through participation” (page 114). Good. Stuff. Here. 
Picture
This leads into the topic of vocation and mate selection. (Looking for an audience of university students, maybe?) The notion that God always chooses the unexpected one (page 120ff) is a hallmark of Scripture, cf. Joseph, David, the twelve disciples, and Paul. This remains true as long as it does not devolve into formulaic renderings of the how God should work. This last third of the book deals with the choice involved in entering adult occupation and finding a lifelong mate. 
Is there a choice in the matter or a magical rendering of what to do and be, not an unfair expectation of a generation reared by the Hogwarts Sorting Hat. If only it was so easy. J. K. Rowling is sleeping on a bed of a billion dollars tonight because she told a story of how not-easy it is to find the direction life may take. The realization that “we are God’s desire” (page 164) is a balm for the anxious young adult wondering what comes next. 
More could have been done to incorporate the shaping of personal choices through participation in various liturgies (page 139), something that James K.A. Smith has made much of in his work Desiring the Kingdom (2009). The authors raise the specter of consumerism as a challenge to divine calling but backed off too quickly, I think. Also, they make an attempt at working through why some choose to follow a “god of the scavenger hunt," so much the subject of young adult literature, moving from one relationship or job to the next looking for an elusive sense of what “feels” right.
The response Fringer and Lane offer is a good one, and frankly, the topic of the entire book in its own right: moving from a hermeneutic of authority (receiving a divine harness) to a hermeneutic of optimism (human hands-on action) to a hermeneutic of love (being responsible to the gift of divine grace). True, sometimes tripping into the arms of God is part of realizing the extent of God's capacity for inviting humanity on a walk with Him into the mystifying tumbles and turns in this mysterious creation.
As I edited this post, I couldn't help but think of "Walk of Life" written by Mark Knopfler, one of my favorite artists, that brings together the themes of this book and why it should strike a chord in the Western mindset with its dual love of music and sports as portrayed in the video below: stumbling, getting back up, enduring, seeking companionship in the midst of pain, trying to do something significant, figuring out faith in the fog, hearing and being heard, and finding a path through the days. 
0 Comments

The Martian by Andy Weir, a resource list for the August book discussion at the Mount Vernon Public Library

8/19/2015

0 Comments

 
Here are resources for getting the most out of the 2014 novel The Martian by Andy Weir, kind of like Apollo 13 meets Castaway, a sci-fi rendition of Daniel Defoe's classic novel Robinson Crusoe. 
Thus, the literary minded call this kind of "stranded-survivor" story a robinsonade.
(click on image to go to Amazon for more about the book and the author)
Mount Vernon and Knox County Public Library (click here for the library website)
Picture
Note: I didn't make the poster, which I like, by the way. It wasn't me, though, that made my name look so large on the page. Sort of screams, "MATT PRICE!!!!" The discussion, however, is all about the book. If you didn't read it, come anyway, and let's talk about Mars, space travel, science fiction, and other good books you've read recently.
Questions to Discuss
  • What do you think it would be like to be the only person on the planet?
  • Identify the struggles that drive the plot of this novel?
  • What problems faced by Mark Watney are most realistic? Or less so?
  • What solutions created by Watney were most ingenuous? Or less so?
  • In what ways could the obstacles be considered man-made or human error? Which ones were just happenstance? At what point if any the issue of blame and responsibility arise in the story?
  • Name the characteristics of Mark Watney that make him a survivor.
  • Describe the character that resonated with you the most besides Watney?
  • Andy Weir has said the technology used in the book is all currently possible except maybe not to the same scale. What technological abilities were mostly unknown to you before reading this book? 
  • What drives the human fascination with space travel, and with Mars in particular?
  • Andy Weir sets this story about one hundred years into the future, around 2115. Do you think the author's vision for traveling to Mars within the next century is even a remote possibility? Why is it worth doing? (or not)
  • Buzz Aldrin talks a lot about space tourism as a way to promote space travel. If given the chance would you travel into orbit, around the moon, even beyond?
  • In your lifetime, would you rather see humanity solve world hunger or travel to Mars?
  • What's your favorite story, book, or film about Mars?
  • What other stories, books, films are similar to The Martian?
Links to Related Books
The Past Dreams
The Present Visions
The Future Imagined
Maps of Mars
Of course, Google's map of Mars.
Geological and topographical map of Mars from the USGS from space.com.
Image gallery of Mars and its exploration from NASA.
The journey taken by Mark Whatney traced on the surface of Mars, for your convenience.
How Far Is it to Mars?
Distance to Mars animated in pixels.
Adam Savage Interviews Andy Weir -- The Talking Room
3:00 | Ion engines explained
4:20 | Delta V (change in velocity) 
5:48 | Vocational background as software programmer
6:48 | How would I put together a mission to Mars and what could go wrong? 
8:20 | All the technology exists but not scaled to the point that it is used in the book
9:25 | Plausibility of Watney's spacesuits--one of the ways Andy messes with current science
11:58 | Wrote a program to simulate orbits and constant acceleration . . . 14:00 | the details involved
12:48 | Written without NASA contacts
13:10 | Reference library is one computer and the wonder of Googling and a high school teacher
16:18 | When Andy describes the process of writing The Martian & the story of how he became a writer
18:30 | How long it took for the novel to be discovered from posting it serially on his blog and going viral to Kindle Direct to a paper publisher taking notice
20:00 | Scientific fact checking from fans
25:50 | Commander Chris Hatfield's appreciation: "How did you get the realisitic sense of being an astronaut so right?" Andy: "No contacts at the space agency, I'm just a space dork."
27:45 | The importance and intensity of astronauts and their ability to work together
29:30 | Perspective change in the narrative continues at 34:20
31:15 | Risk from the engineer to management
31:40 | Watney starts naming stuff after himself
32:10 | Visit to JPL 
33:20 | Watney triangle and pirate ninjas at JPL
34:45 | Adam's emotional response similar to the audience's helplessness to Watney's predicament
36:11 | Chemist fact checks the hydrazine
38:23 | Andy knows things that are really hard to learn about space travel
39:15 | Could have not brought cannisters with him
39:50 | Pull quotes from Chris Hatfield and Larry Niven
40:30 | Showing the math and makes it exciting
43:53 | Dead ends in the plot: start with problem and how does Watney solve it: cascade failures
45:40 | Backtracking to make forward progress
46:00 | Influence of Apollo 13 : make a whole book of that
47:07 | Armstrong solving the spinning capsule
49:00 | John W Young: a favorite astronaut
51:30 | Organization of research
52:20 | NASA has not asked for help
53:00 | Thoughts on the film Gravity & suspension of disbelief
The Martian film trailer (2015)
The Hermes Crew
Andy Weir, The Martian - Talks at Google
The Martian by Andy Weir audio book, part 1 with links to the rest
The Egg by Andy Weir, a short story in audio narration
0 Comments

Nazarene Pastors | Church of the Nazarene Presence in the Great Lakes Megaregion 1900-2014

8/4/2015

0 Comments

 
According to statistics available from 2014,

There are 1418 current pastors in the Great Lakes Megaregion (consisting of 26 Nazarene districts).

Note: "Current pastors" is defined as the reporting pastor for the local church at district assembly and the one designated pastor in the district journals. 

245 churches in this megaregion are without a current pastor.

The median tenure of current pastors on the megaregion is 5 years, 
meaning they have been in place since 2010. 

Another way to put it: 
Half of the current pastors have been at their assignments 
for five years or less.

57 is the median worship attendance at a church  with a current pastor. (There are as many churches with current pastors with fewer than 57 in attendance as there are churches with more in attendance.) Conclusion: Small churches are normal churches.

Three out of ten (29%) current pastors have been in their local church assignment for less than two years.

Three out of ten (29%) of current pastors have been in their local church assignment for more than eleven years.

Reflections
(TL;dr | Probably enough ministry grads to fill the gap of pastor-less churches, the need to connect veteran pastors with newbies, & a little something about John Maxwell and Rob Bell to tick off veterans and newbies at least a little bit, probably)

A couple of thoughts go swimming through my mind when I see these statistics. 

First of all.

There are 245 churches without a current pastor. I can't speak for Eastern Nazarene College, Olivet Nazarene University, Nazarene Bible College, and Nazarene Theological Seminary though I am familiar with ministry graduates from Mount Vernon Nazarene University. These universities and graduate schools all serve districts within the Great Lakes Megaregion. 

I am almost certain we didn't have more than a combined 245 graduates in 2014. We did, however, graduate enough to fill some of the missing pulpits, right? Just asking. 

Secondly.

There are a lot of new pastors, or at least those new to their local contexts. They have been where they are for two years. I can't even remember my address in less than two years, but I've had a lot of addresses.

There are not many true veterans out there. The median tenure is five years. Anyone who has been in full-time ministry can give grin-worthy and grimace-inducing answers to the question, what could go wrong in that amount of time? But, are they really veterans yet--those who have endured the worst and the best?

True, I think a pastor on-site for five years knows the terrain. I've been in Mount Vernon for six years this summer, and there's a lot that I've learned in the past month that I didn't know before. 

It's possible that a pastor on-site for five years or more FEELS like a veteran, probably with battle scars to prove it. I think serving in ministry should be counted in dog years. You know, every year in ministry should count as seven in any other vocation. A pastor might think, "I've been here for five years, but it feels like 35"--the span of an entire career for anyone else. Ready for retirement? Not yet, but at least half of pastors on this megaregion see the five-year mark as time to move on--before they've had time to smell the air.

At the other end of the spectrum, there are the same number of pastors that have been on-site for eleven years or more as there are those with two years of experience. That's difficult to comprehend: Less than two years and more than eleven make up 60% of the pastoral corps. Eleven years equals an old-timer in our Great Lakes tribe.

Eleven years--this is enough time for toddlers in the family to grow up and move on to adulthood. It's enough time to pay off a car or two. There's enough ministry experience in eleven years to know that friendships fizzle, leadership changes, and people shuffle through churches like an old pack of cards. 

It is enough time to reveal real strengths in the midst of polite flattery ("Nice sermon, pastor!") as well as true weaknesses and not just someone going through a bad season ("How could giving drop $45,000 in three years?"). These discoveries not always happy or easy. 
To make it to eleven years in a single church most likely means the pastor has left behind the idealistic years of the twenty-something or the it-could-always-improve thirties. The reality of long-haul ministry has set in, callouses have developed so words do not hurt as much, wishes are replaced with prayers. Prayers sometimes leak out as a resigned sigh, a wry smile or a triune "hmph."
It is also enough time to have something to say to the next generation or to the pastor newly arrived. 

What can we do to get these two groups together? First, I get the hesitation. Why put a grumpy, sarcastic pastor together with a newby? Secondly, why frustrate an already overworked pastor with the new guy that thinks he smells like Rob Bell? (Because of the Axe hair paste.)
Picture
Because messy hair - lifemartini.com
Somehow we need to make this connection work between veterans and newbies. I think veterans need to know that newbies are not out to knock down the church with a wrecking ball of new ideas. They are not out to steal sheep. They are not there to make them suspicious or challenge their seniority.

Remember how awful it was that one time when the group of long-haired young people called Petra tried to bring "that rock music" into the church? Now they are fellow inductees in the Gospel Music Hall of Fame alongside Jake Hess. Let that sink in a bit before continuing.

Now, replace Petra with Rob Bell, open theism, social justice, creation care, and skinny jeans. I think it'll all work out. 

Rob Bell will get old like John Maxwell, and the celebrity will fade. Fun facts: Both have good hair (um, used to?), a thing for sweaters (different styles, though), sold a load of books & left churches to do the conference circuit. Ironic, no? 
Picture
Picture
Source: Relevant Media Group

Open theism will eventually be seen to fit partially though awkwardly into the Arminian half of "Wesleyan-Arminian"; social justice is just plain gospel for everyone; creation care is simply Genesis Two stewardship; and, potluck dinners will make skinny jeans obsolete. For every Stryper, there was a Petra. For every Rob Bell and John Maxwell, there is a Francis Chan. For every new idea, there's a better one yet to be thought up. 

And, for each new generation there's another one coming up. Let's make a place/role/opportunity for the veterans to give the newbies a hand in the things that really matter.
Picture

Infograph

Picture

Great Lakes Megaregion Map

Picture
Related posts
  • Women in Ministry | Church of the Nazarene Presence in the Great Lakes Megaregion 1900-2014
  • Large Churches | Church of the Nazarene Presence in the Great Lakes Megaregion 1900-2014
  • Ethnic Churches | Church of the Nazarene Presence in the Great Lakes Megaregion 1900-2014
  • Churches Closed | Church of the Nazarene Presence in the Great Lakes Megaregion 1900-2014
  • Church of the Nazarene Presence in the Great Lakes Megaregion 1900-2014
  • Great Lakes Megaregion and the Church of the Nazarene
  • Megaregions and the Church in North America
  • Megaregion in the Making -- Beijing's Jing-Jin-Ji
Sources
www.america.2050.org
Nazarene Research Services, Lenexa, KS
Church of the Nazarene District Journals 2014
Raw Data - Nazarene Research Services - June 2015
0 Comments

Geographic Expanse & Urbanization | Church of the Nazarene Presence in the Great Lakes Megaregion 1900-2014

8/3/2015

0 Comments

 
Megaregions are not a typical way of talking about north American geography. We typically use the designations of states/provinces, cities, and towns. 

This post offers an overview of the states, provinces and largest cities within the Great Lakes Megaregion. 

Beside each city is the 2014 population estimate and the number of Nazarene congregations with a physical address in these cities within the Great Lakes Megaregion.
Twelve U.S. States
Kentucky, Indiana, Illinois, Kansas, Michigan, Minneapolis, Missouri, New York (upstate), North Dakota, Ohio, Pennsylvania (western side), South Dakota, Wisconsin

Two Canadian provinces
Ontario, Quebec
Seventeen of the Top 100 U.S. Cities by Population (over 215,000)
93 Nazarene congregations with a physical address in the city
3 Chicago, Illinois pop. 2,722,389 (11 Nazarene congregations)
14 Indianapolis, Indiana pop. 843,375 (17 Nazarene congregations)
15 Columbus, Ohio pop. 835,957 (5 Nazarene congregations)
18 Detroit, Michigan pop. 680,250 (2 Nazarene congregations)
30 Louisville, Kentucky pop. 599, 642 (7 Nazarene congregations)
31 Milwaukee, Wisconsin pop. 599, 164 (1 Nazarene congregation)
37 Kansas City, Missouri pop. 470, 800 (13 Nazarene congregations)
46 Minneapolis, Minnesota pop. 407,207 (2 Nazarene congregations)
48 Cleveland, Ohio pop. 389,521 (4 Nazarene congregations)
60 St. Louis, Missouri pop.317,419 (0 Nazarene congregations)
61 Lexington-Fayette, Kentucky pop. 310,797 (6 Nazarene congregations)
62 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania pop. 305,412 (1 Nazarene congregation)
65 Cincinnati, Ohio pop. 298,165 (14 Nazarene congregations)
66 St Paul, Minnesota pop. 297,640 (1 Nazarene congeragtion)
68 Toledo, Ohio pop. 281,031 (2 Nazarene congregations)
77 Fort Wayne, Indiana pop. 258,522 (6 Nazarene congregations)
83 Madison, Wisconsin pop. 245,691 (1 Nazarene congregation)
Source: Baruch College - World Cities & District Journals
Twelve out of 33 cities in Canada over 125,000 people (2014 estimates)
31 Nazarene congregations with a physical address in the city
(cities listed below have populations approximate to the top 100 cities in the U.S.)
Toronto (Ont) pop. 6,055,700 (8 Nazarene congregations)
Montreal (Que) pop.  4,027,100 (10 Nazarene congregations)
Ottawa-Gastineau (Ont./Que.) pop.  1,318,100 (2 Nazarene congregations)
Quebec City (Ont.) pop.  799,600
Hamilton (Ont.) pop. 765,200 (3 Nazarene congregations)
Kitchener-Cambridge-Waterloo (Ont.) pop. 506,900 (1 Nazarene congregation)
London (Ont) pop. 502,400 (2 Nazarene congregations)
St. Catharines-Niagara (Ont) pop. 405,900 (1 Nazarene congregation)
Oshawa (Ont) pop. 384,100 (1 Nazarene congregation)
Windsor (Ont) pop. 333,900 (1 Nazarene congregation)
Sherbrooke (Que) pop. 212,100 (1 Nazarene congregation)
Barrie (Ont) pop. 200,400 (1 Nazarene church congregation)
Source: Statistics Canada & District Journals 2014

Two of the Top 100 World Cities by population
37 Chicago, IL-IN-WI 9,156,000
53 Toronto, ON, Canada 6,456,000 (demographics & neighborhood profiles): 
Sources: Baruch College - World Cities & Toronto.ca
0 Comments
    Picture
    Picture

    Bio

    teacher, writer,
    talker, do-er

    Type Seven.
    ​
    Supposed Strengths:
    ideation, activator, strategic, learner, positivity

    Tweets by @JaMaPrice
    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    August 2022
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2020
    November 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014

    RSS Feed


    Categories

    All
    Africa
    Asia
    Autobiographical
    Bible
    Books
    Church
    Coffee
    COVID-19
    Diversity
    Film
    Folk Beliefs
    Holiness
    Intercultural Studies
    Luther
    Megaregions
    Microchurch
    Ordination
    Organic Church
    Public Library
    Road Trip
    Sci Fi
    Sci-Fi
    Skeptics
    Suggested Reading
    Theology
    Training Video
    Urban

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Blog
  • Megaregions
  • Courses
  • Trip Info
  • C.V. & Research
  • Transformational Ministry
  • Contact
    • About
  • French
  • Missional Church
  • Gospel & Culture
  • Global Diversity
  • History | Church of the Nazarene